Voice of the Customer

TMCnet - The World's Largest Communications and Technology Community
New Coverage :  Asterisk  |  Call Center Outsourcing  |  Call Recording  |  SIP Trunking  |  Hosted Exchange  |  PBX
Webinars
Channels by Topic
Share
 
| More
RSS-XML alerts
Print this page
E-mail this page to a friend
Voice of the Customer Featured Article Archive

TMCNet: EDITORIAL: FTC blogger rules chill online speech

[October 24, 2009]

EDITORIAL: FTC blogger rules chill online speech

Oct 24, 2009 (Tampa Tribune - McClatchy-Tribune Information Services via COMTEX) -- THE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION -- the nation's chief regulator of advertising -- is trying too hard to keep consumers from being misled by Internet bloggers. The agency's new rules put unprecedented restrictions on freedom of speech.

In the first revisions of regulations on product endorsements and testimonials since 1980, the FTC says that effective Dec. 1, all online writers will have to disclose whether they're getting money or free goods from companies for reviewing products.

The rules don't apply to the old media -- newspapers, magazines and TV. That's unfair to the new media -- blogs, social networks and personal Web sites.

The real problem of well-financed advertisers masquerading as unbiased reviewers can be solved short of chilling the entire Internet conversation.

The FTC is correct that some bloggers are misleading consumers, who may be unaware that an Internet writer is compensated to tout certain products. The FTC's solution is to require all bloggers to disclose any commercial relationship, such as receiving a free product to review, even if the company sending the product has no control over what the bloggers say and even if the value of the product is small.

A blogger and the company providing the compensation each could be fined up to $11,000 for a violation, and they might even be required to reimburse shoppers.

The FTC is right that reviews and testimonials by ordinary people can be persuasive and that transparency would help consumers make informed decisions. But the nation's founders were wise enough to know that the credibility of the press is not a function of the zeal of regulators.

Already consumers flock to trustworthy Internet sites that are free of commercial bias and are run with journalistic integrity. Credibility is a main selling point of established media outlets that are largely self-regulated.

When the FTC states that "self-regulation works best when backed up by a strong law enforcement presence," every journalist should pay attention.

The FTC defends its regulatory foray into the near infinity of Internet communications by saying that "to the extent that consumers' willingness to trust social media depends on the ability of those media to retain their credibility as reliable sources of information, (regulation) presumably would have a beneficial, not detrimental, effect." Presumably, the folks at the FTC aren't intimidated by the volume of traffic on Twitter, Facebook and MySpace, to mention a few. Presumably they're not worried that the assumption of federal oversight would give unfair advantage to anyone willing to abuse the system, operate from a foreign country or blog in someone else's name.

The FTC should first target the many Internet pros who receive substantial compensation, and the companies paying it, and see how effective those rules are before going after networking hobbyists. It should try exposing the true marketers, not the amateur reviewers and volunteer bloggers. Anyone earning a living hawking products has entered the advertising business and has invited federal oversight. There are enough of them to keep regulators busy.

Nothing is wrong with a company providing review copies of merchandise of minor value to bloggers. Disclosure should be up to the individual or company, as has long been the practice in newspapers that review books.

Even amid the countless sources of news and opinion on the Internet, the public understands that most professional journalists uphold long-established ethical standards. It is a good reason to rely on established brands for news, opinion and reviews. Individual bloggers must build their own credibility, and many of them have.

It is important that the FTC rule writers make a clear distinction between honest reviewers with an opinion and slick marketers whose opinion has been purchased.

Blurring this distinction will bring unneeded regulatory costs and censorship to the free-flowing Internet conversation.

To see more of the Tampa Tribune or to subscribe to the newspaper, go to http://www.tampatrib.com. Copyright (c) 2009, Tampa Tribune, Fla. Distributed by McClatchy-Tribune Information Services. For reprints, email tmsreprints@permissionsgroup.com, call 800-374-7985 or 847-635-6550, send a fax to 847-635-6968, or write to The Permissions Group Inc., 1247 Milwaukee Ave., Suite 303, Glenview, IL 60025, USA.

[ Back To Voice of the Customer Community's Homepage ]
› Return to Voice of the Customer Home

FOLLOW US

FREE Voice of the Customer eNewsletter

Subscribe Now

Featured White Papers

  • Seven Best Practices for Speech Analytics: Speech analytics is valuable for identifying issues in the contact center. However, limiting its use to the contact center only considers a portion of all customer interactions and subsequently only reveals a small part of the voice of the customer. This paper discusses how organizations can optimize their Speech Analytics implementation strategy to realize the promise of this exciting technology.
  • Understanding the Voice of the Customer: Today's contact centers involve a sea of information that must be captured, processed, and distributed on a daily basis. Effective use of this information enables companies to remain competitive in an increasingly aggressive and customer centric marketplace. An overwhelming percentage of the information that circulates in a contact center's audio recordings, documents, web pages, and emails is unstructured in that it resides outside of a normal structured database and cannot be managed efficiently. These unstructured items contain valuable information, yet this information historically has been difficult to organize, categorize, and access.
View All ›

Case Studies

  • Aflac: Aflac, the leading provider of guaranteed-renewable insurance turned to Autonomy to help them automate the process of monitoring their contact center agent for quality and compliance. The company now has a system that can offer continued improvement in agent quality and productivity while enhancing the customer experience. ...
  • Avaya: Avaya, a global leader in business communications, inherited 880 websites as well as numerous intranets and extranets when it was spun off from Lucent Technologies. The sheer volume and diversity of the sites and the over 500 content creators resulted in inefficient content distribution rife with divergent branding, messaging, and product information. ...
View All ›

Video Showcase

    Interview with Autonomy: Rich Tehrani interviews Simon Hayhurst, SVP of Autonomy

Featured Events

  • Multichannel Analytics with Autonomy Explore: In today's world of constant connectivity there are a variety of direct and indirect channels of communication between an enterprise (or a brand) and its customers. 80% of these valuable interactions are generated in a human-friendly, unstructured format across multiple touchpoints and channels. With this ever growing mountain of information how do you extract the emerging trends and topics of interest to the enterprise? ...
  • SES Chicago 2011: Marketers and SEO professionals attend SES Chicago each year to network and learn about topics such as PPC management, keyword research, SEO, social media, local, mobile, link building, duplicate content, multiple site issues, video optimization, site optimization, usability and more. The conference offers 70+ sessions, intensive training workshops, and an expo floor packed with companies that can help you grow your business. While you're at it, network with peers and leading industry vendors. Programmed by the SES advisory board, you can be assured - SES content really is king! ...
View All ›
 
Share
 
| More
RSS-XML alerts
Print this page
E-mail this page to a friend